2016-17 - Justin Hoch, JHoch.com (NY)
2015-16 - Mark Lundy, Lutte-Lens (MO)
2014-15 - John Sachs, Tech-Fall.com (CA)
2013-14 - Mark Beshey, The Guillotine (MN)
2012-13 - Austin Bernard, OklahomaWrestling.org (OK)
2011-12 - Brooke Zumas, PA
2010-11 – Tony Nordland, TheMatSlap.com (NY)
2009-10 – Tony Rotundo, Tech-Fall.com (CA)
2008-09 – Larry Slater, AZ
2007-08 – Danielle Hobeika, AmateurWrestlingPhotos.com (NY)
2006-07 – Jeff Nolan, CT
2005-06 – John Sachs, Tech-Fall.com (CA)
2004-05 – Marc Sprague, OR
2003-04 – Andre Reddington, Amateur Wrestling News (OK)
2002-03 – Tim Tushla, W.I.N. Magazine (IA)
2001-02 – G. Wyatt Schultz, The Predicament (IA)
2000-01 – John Johnson, Amateur Wrestling News (IA)
1999-00 – Kevin Allen, MD
1998-99 – Ginger Robinson, IL
1997-98 – Casey B. Gibson, CO
1996-97 – Sonja Stanbro, NY
1995-96 – Jim Butler, PA
1994-95 – Dr. Marshall Goldstein, PA
1993-94 – Chris Poff, PA
1992-93 – Steve Brown, CO
1991-92 – Rick Chitwood, IN