Division I SID of the Year
2022-23 - Kaylie Noll, University of Arkansas-Little Rock
2021-22 - Chris Brewer, University of Iowa (2)
2020-21 - Joe Wedra, University of North Carolina
2019-20 - Stacie Michaud, U.S. Naval Academy
2018-19 - Brian Reinhardt, NC State
2017-18 - Leah Howard, University of Michigan
2016-17 - Chas Dorman, University of Pennsylvania
2015-16 - Chris Brewer, University of Iowa
2014-15 - Taylor Miller, Oklahoma State University
2013-14 - Bryan Johnston, Virginia Tech
2012-13 - Tanner Lipsett, Purdue University

Small College SID of the Year
2022-23 - Kerry Kahl, Cornell College
2021-22 - Don Stoner, Augsburg University (3)
2020-21 - Billy Mangum, Life University
2019-20 - Chris Caputo, University of Pittsburgh-Johnstown
2018-19 - Corey Jewart, Gettysburg College
2017-18 - Howie Thompson, Upper Iowa University
2016-17 - Rich Tortorelli, Oklahoma City University
2015-16 - Josh Manck, Newberry College
2014-15 - Jackie Paquette, University of Indianapolis
2013-14 - Tom Nelson, St. Cloud State University
2012-13 - Don Stoner, Augsburg College (2)

Combined Awards
2011-12 - Steve Lomangino, Lehigh University
2010-11 – Amanda Dahl, NAIA
2009-10 – Aaron Voos, University of Wyoming
2008-09 – Pat Donghia, Penn State University
2007-08 – Leah Howard, University of Michigan
2006-07 – Colin McDonough, University of Northern Iowa
2005-06 – Jim Sheehan, Hofstra
2004-05 – Emily Gatewood, University of Missouri
2003-04 – Don Stoner, Augsburg and Mark Adkins, Wartburg
2002-03 – Brian Siegrist, Penn State University
2001-02 – Kevin Kurtt, University of Minnesota
2000-01 – Traci Wagner, University of Iowa
1999-00 – Susan Filkins, University of Minnesota
1998-99 – Rich Herman, Clarion
1997-98 – Mike Kirk, Central Oklahoma
1996-97 – Unknown
1995-96 – Steve Kirschner, University of North Carolina
1994-95 – Ryan Finney, Purdue
1993-94 – Cornell Bass, Maryland USA Wrestling
1992-93 – Phil Haddy, University of Iowa
1991-92 – Gary Abbott, USA Wrestling